In the quiet Amish community of Hickory Hollow in the state of Pennsylvania, time has stood still. In this environment, cherished traditions and deep faith thrive. However, amidst the community, a secret exists that could shake the tranquility of its residents. When Katie Lapp accidentally discovers a satin baby dress in an old trunk in her parents' attic, she knows that this dress wants to tell a story. On the evening before her wedding to the widowed Bishop Johannes, she learns from her parents the shocking truth. Katie is unprepared for the devastating uprooting that this confession means for her life. She feels betrayed and must watch as the only life she knows falls apart, while at the same time, it opens up a hopeful future for her.