Wouldn't an infinite life also be infinitely boring? The assumption that human mortality is a prerequisite for a desirable life is widespread. But can it be upheld? Marianne Kreuels engages with the various arguments for this position, as presented by Bernard Williams and Martha Nussbaum, among others, and demonstrates that they are all unconvincing. Through numerous illustrative thought experiments, she elucidates in her insightful essay that an infinite life can also be a desirable life that does not have to differ from that of a mortal, aside from its length, of course.